Subclinical Hypocalcemia Costs $125 Per Affected Cow. Here Are 4 Steps To Prevent It.
October 22, 2020
Cases of clinical hypocalcemia (milk fever) are rare on Nobis Dairy, reaching only single digits most years in the operation’s 1,000-cow Holstein herd.
“We have a pretty aggressive treatment program with calcium when cows calve, so deficiencies are not typically a problem for us,” says Kerry Nobis, St. Johns, Mich.
So it was with some surprise that when Nobis decided to check some of the cows for subclinical hypocalcemia (SCH) earlier this fall, he found it.
“There were a handful of animals that were probably in their third lactation or greater that had lower calcium than I would have expected, especially just looking at them because they looked good,” Nobis recalls.
What Nobis experienced is far more common than most dairy producers realize, according to Jesse Goff, Iowa State University professor and dairy veterinarian.
“Subclinical hypocalcemia occurs in nearly half of all cows during the first 24 hours after calving,” Goff says. “It results when calcium levels go below 8 mg/dl.”
He attributes hypocalcemia, including the subclinical stage, to metabolic alkalosis. “The cows are alkalotic as a result of the potassium in the forages they are fed,” he says.
“Alkalosis blocks the action of a calcium regulating hormone, called parathyroid hormone, on the bone and kidney of the cow. This impairs the cow’s ability to adapt to blood calcium lost to colostrum and milk at the onset of lactation,” he adds.
SCH cows don’t display traditional signs of hypocalcemia, such as lethargy, cold ears or being unable to stand. Instead, they are likely to consume less feed and produce less milk, both of which impact productivity and profitability.
“Depending on how quickly cows recover, subclinical hypocalcemic cows may produce less milk in the first week of lactation relative to what they would have given otherwise,” reports Donna Amaral-Phillips, University of Kentucky Extension dairy specialist.
In addition, Garrett Oetzel, University of Wisconsin professor and dairy veterinarian, reports that SCH is associated with an increased risk for metritis, post-partum fever, post-fresh BHBA (beta-hydroxybutyrate acid) and longer median days open, 124 versus 109 days.
Amaral-Phillips says financial losses to subclinical hypocalcemia average approximately $125 per affected cow.
Nobis’ reaction to finding SCH in some of his cows was to supplement them with calcium, based on blood test results determined by a portable, calcium blood-testing machine, the Lab 004, which is manufactured by Japan-based Arkray, Inc.
“Our treated cows recovered fine, and the experience reaffirmed that an aggressive program of getting calcium into those cows is worth the money we put into it,” he says. Nobis adds that much of the success the farm has with keeping hypocalcemia at bay is due to his employees’ dedication.
Citing research conducted by Jessica McArt, DVM, Cornell University, Goff says it is persistent hypocalcemia into day two of lactation that most often results in cows that end up being culled.
“If you can only take one blood sample from cows to assess your transition program success, I would choose to take a blood sample as close to 36 hours after calving as possible,” he recommends. The reason is cows that are still below 8.0 mg/dl may be more likely to develop problems such as metritis and a displaced abomasum.
“If I could take two blood samples, I would take one at 12 hours after calving and again at 36 hours after calving,” he adds. “If your transition program is working, most of the cows will have a higher blood calcium concentration at 36 hours than they did at calving.”
Goff’s perspective is because every dairy is different, addressing hypocalcemia through prevention is not a one-size-fits-all venture. He offers four recommendations for dairy producers’ consideration:
1. Reduce close-up (prefresh) diet potassium. “Focus on procuring or growing low-potassium grasses for dry cow diets by avoiding manure application to fields used to grow dry cow forage,” he recommends. Also, harvest grasses when more mature than perhaps you have in the past, as mature forages contain less potassium. “Use warm season grasses when possible for a portion of the dry cow diet; corn silage is a warm season grass,” he adds.
2. Consider adding anions to the diet to acidify the cow to restore tissue sensitivity to the calcium-regulating parathyroid hormone. Goff says many nutritionists utilize ration balancing programs that will calculate the diet cation-anion difference (DCAD). “The diet should be formulated to be between -75 and -125 mEq/kg diet, depending on the anion source used,” he says. Urine pH can be tested to ensure the proper anion content. Goff says when urine pH of the herd averages between 6.0 and 6.6 the week before calving, the diet is correct. Below 5.5 pH you have excessive acidification. “The cows will reduce their dry matter intake to avoid over-acidification,” he adds. “Above a 7.25 pH there will be little improvement in blood calcium.”
3. Another strategy Goff recommends is to bind the diet calcium for at least 10 days before calving. “When successful, the cow's body is tricked into thinking it is calcium deficient and it begins to produce hormones to increase diet calcium absorption and bone calcium resorption mechanisms prior to calving,” he explains. “The result is when these systems are up-regulated the cow can readily adapt to the onset of lactation.”
With both diet strategies, it is important to provide a readily available source of magnesium to the cow. The reason is cows that are hypomagnesemic will struggle with calcium homeostasis as well, Goff explains. He says diet magnesium should be about 0.4%. “We also think diet phosphorus should be kept below 0.3% for optimum calcium homeostasis at calving,” he adds.
4. Another option is to provide a readily available (soluble) calcium source to the cow immediately after calving. Oral calcium boluses on the market generally contain calcium chloride or propionate which is rapidly soluble. Drenches or gels containing calcium can be very effective but require more skilled labor to administer to the cow. Goff says administering calcium can be repeated 12 to 24 hours after calving. Providing intravenous calcium for high-risk cows at calving is no longer warranted, he says. “It seems to impair the calcium homeostasis adaptation mechanisms, so the cow is actually more hypocalcemic on day two of lactation,” he explains “Subcutaneous calcium may be helpful, but it generally requires injection into five or more sites to avoid sterile – and maybe not so sterile – abscess formation.”